Advanced Roofing Inc Logo
Advanced Roofing Inc.
Building Tomorrow’s Roofs Today!
Call Our Roofing Experts!
(630) 553-2344

What Illinois Homeowners Regret Most About Their Roof Replacement—And How to Avoid It

June 27, 2025 / Written by: Advanced Roofing Inc.

June 27, 2025
Written by: Advanced Roofing Inc.

Key Takeaways:

  1. Low-cost roof jobs often use worse materials or skip important steps, leading to leaks and damage later. Pay a little more now to save big later.
  2. Look at reviews and ask for past work examples. Good roofers won't rush you into signing a contract.
  3. A roof needs proper airflow to last. Bad attic ventilation can wreck your new roof fast.
  4. Rotted wood or mold under old shingles can surprise you. A full inspection first prevents budget shocks.
  5. Even the best roof needs checkups and small fixes to avoid big problems. Clean gutters and fix minor issues early.

Let’s face it—getting a new roof isn’t cheap. And when Illinois homeowners rush into a roof replacement project without planning, they often end up with regrets. Maybe they picked the wrong roofing materials, skipped a roof inspection, or hired the wrong roofing company. Whatever the reason, these mistakes can lead to water damage, costly repairs, and even structural issues down the road.

The good news? You can avoid these headaches if you know what to watch for. Here’s what most people wish they’d done differently—and how you can get it right from the start.

Regret #1: Choosing the Cheapest Option (Instead of the Best Value)

We get it—when you see a low price for a roof replacement, it’s tempting to jump on it. But here’s the problem: cheap often means cutting corners. Some roofing contractors use lower-quality asphalt shingles, skip proper underlayment, or rush the installation process. A few years later, you’re dealing with roof leaks, water stains, and even structural damage.

The fix? Get multiple quotes, but don’t just pick the cheapest. Look for a professional roofing contractor with good reviews, proper compensation insurance, and a solid warranty. A few extra dollars now can save you thousands later.

Regret #2: Not Checking the Roofing Company’s Reputation

Not all roofing companies are the same. Some show up, slap on a new roof, and disappear, leaving you with minor issues that turn into big problems. Others take their time, follow building codes, and make sure your roof lasts.

How do you tell the difference? Check online reviews, ask for references, and make sure they’re licensed. A good roofing company won’t mind showing you past work. And if they pressure you to sign fast? That’s a red flag.

Regret #3: Ignoring Ventilation and Insulation

A roof isn’t just shingles—it’s a system. If your attic doesn’t have proper ventilation, heat and moisture get trapped. That can warp your roof deck, melt asphalt shingles faster, and even hurt your home’s energy efficiency.

What should you do? Ask your roofing contractors about attic ventilation. A good roofer will check airflow and suggest fixes if needed. It might cost a little extra now, but it’ll save your roof—and your energy bills—later.

Regret #4: Not Planning for Hidden Problems

You think you’re just replacing shingles, then the crew starts tearing off the old roof and finds rotted wood, broken decking, or mold. Now your roof replacement project just got more expensive.

How to avoid this? A roof inspection before the job starts can spot hidden damage. A professional roofer will check the decking, flashing, and structure so you know the real cost upfront. No surprises.

Regret #5: Picking the Wrong Roofing Materials

Not all roofing materials work the same in Illinois weather. Some fade fast under the sun, some can’t handle heavy snow, and others get wrecked by a hailstorm. If you pick the wrong one, you’ll be repairing or replacing it sooner than you’d like.

What’s the solution? Talk to your roofing company about the best options for your area. Asphalt shingles are popular (and affordable), but metal or impact-resistant shingles might be better if you get bad storms.

Regret #6: Skipping Regular Maintenance After Installation

Some folks think a new roof means zero worries for 20 years. Not true. Without regular roof maintenance, small problems (like cracked flashing or clogged gutters) turn into water damage or even structural issues.

What should you do? Schedule regular inspections, especially after big storms. Clean your gutters, trim overhanging branches, and fix minor issues before they get worse. A little care keeps your roof in great shape.

Regret #7: Not Thinking About Curb Appeal

Your roof is a huge part of your home’s look. Pick clashing colors or mismatched shingles, and your curb appeal takes a hit. Some homeowners even regret not upgrading to nicer roofing materials when they had the chance.

How to get it right? Look at samples in different lighting. A good roofing contractor can show you how colors will look on your house. And if you’re planning to sell soon, a stylish roof can boost your home’s value.

Regret #8: Assuming Insurance Will Cover Everything

After a bad storm, some homeowners rush into a roof replacement expecting their insurance company to pay for it all. But insurance doesn’t always cover wear and tear—just sudden damage (like from hail or wind). If your roof was already old, you might get stuck with a big bill.

What’s the smart move? Read your policy, document damage fast, and work with a roofing company that knows how to handle insurance companies. They can help you get the best claim possible.

Need a Roof Replacement Done Right? We Can Help.

A new roof is a big investment, and you shouldn’t have regrets later. At Advanced Roofing Inc., we make sure your roof replacement project goes smoothly from start to finish. We use top-quality roofing materials, follow all building codes, and stand by our work.

No surprises. No shortcuts. Just a roof that lasts.

Ready to replace your roof the right way? Contact Advanced Roofing Inc today for a free, no-pressure inspection!

Advanced Roofing Inc.
At Advanced Roofing Inc., we put our customers’ needs first by providing trained installers, high-quality materials and reliable service that can’t be matched by other roofing companies.

Request A Quote

We're dedicated to providing exceptional service and ensuring your satisfaction. Please don't hesitate to reach out to us with any questions, inquiries, or to schedule a consultation.
Please enable JavaScript in your browser to complete this form.
Advanced Roofing Inc Logo
Advanced Roofing Inc.
At Advanced Roofing Inc., we put our customers’ needs first by providing trained installers, high-quality materials and reliable service that can’t be matched by other roofing companies.
Services
Get In Touch
Working Hours:
Monday to Friday: 9:00AM - 4:00PM
Saturday:  By appointment only
© 2025 Advanced Roofing Inc. All Rights Reserved.
DMCA.com Protection Status